In the field of water treatment, the selection of coagulants plays a crucial role in achieving efficient and cost - effective results. Two commonly used coagulants are polyaluminium chloride (PAC) and aluminum sulfate. As a polyaluminium chloride PAC supplier, I have witnessed firsthand the diverse applications and performance of these two substances in various water treatment scenarios. In this blog, I will compare PAC and aluminum sulfate in water treatment, highlighting their differences in terms of chemical properties, performance, cost - effectiveness, and environmental impact.
Chemical Properties
Polyaluminium Chloride PAC
Polyaluminium Chloride PAC is a highly efficient inorganic polymer coagulant. Its chemical formula can be generally expressed as [Al₂(OH)ₙCl₆₋ₙ]ₘ, where n is between 1 and 5, and m ≤ 10. PAC exists in different basicity levels, which determine its chemical reactivity and coagulation performance. The high - molecular - weight polymeric structure of PAC allows it to form large and dense flocs quickly during the coagulation process. You can learn more about Polyaluminium Chloride PAC on our website.
Aluminum Sulfate
Aluminum sulfate, with the chemical formula Al₂(SO₄)₃, is an inorganic salt. It is a white crystalline solid that is highly soluble in water. When dissolved in water, aluminum sulfate hydrolyzes to form aluminum hydroxide, which acts as a coagulant. However, the hydrolysis process of aluminum sulfate is relatively complex and is highly dependent on the pH of the water.
Coagulation Performance
Floc Formation
One of the most significant differences between PAC and aluminum sulfate is the speed and quality of floc formation. PAC can form large, dense, and fast - settling flocs in a wide range of pH values (usually between 5 - 9). This is due to its pre - polymerized structure, which allows it to react quickly with impurities in the water. In contrast, aluminum sulfate may require a more precise pH adjustment to form effective flocs. At low pH values, the hydrolysis of aluminum sulfate may be incomplete, resulting in poor flocculation. At high pH values, the aluminum hydroxide formed may redissolve, reducing the coagulation efficiency.
Turbidity Removal
PAC generally shows better turbidity removal performance compared to aluminum sulfate. In a study conducted on a surface water treatment plant, the use of PAC reduced the turbidity of the water from 50 NTU to less than 1 NTU, while aluminum sulfate only achieved a turbidity reduction to around 3 NTU under the same conditions. The high - molecular - weight polymers in PAC can effectively bridge and entrap suspended particles, leading to more efficient turbidity removal.
Removal of Organic Matter
Both PAC and aluminum sulfate can remove organic matter from water. However, PAC is more effective in removing dissolved organic matter, such as humic and fulvic acids. These organic substances can cause color, odor, and taste problems in water and may also react with disinfectants to form harmful disinfection by - products. PAC can form complexes with organic matter through charge neutralization and adsorption, facilitating its removal from the water.
Cost - Effectiveness
Chemical Dosage
The dosage of coagulant required to achieve a certain level of water treatment is an important factor in cost - effectiveness. PAC usually requires a lower dosage compared to aluminum sulfate to achieve the same level of coagulation performance. This is because of its higher charge density and stronger coagulation ability. For example, in a wastewater treatment plant treating industrial wastewater, the dosage of PAC was found to be 20 - 30% lower than that of aluminum sulfate to achieve the same level of turbidity removal.
Treatment Cost
Although the unit price of PAC may be higher than that of aluminum sulfate, the lower dosage requirement and better performance of PAC can result in lower overall treatment costs. In addition, the use of PAC may reduce the need for additional chemicals, such as pH adjusters, which can further reduce the treatment cost.
Environmental Impact
Residual Aluminum
One of the environmental concerns in water treatment is the presence of residual aluminum in the treated water. High levels of residual aluminum can be harmful to human health and aquatic life. PAC generally leaves less residual aluminum in the treated water compared to aluminum sulfate. This is because PAC has a more efficient coagulation process, which reduces the amount of unreacted aluminum in the water.


Sludge Production
The amount of sludge produced during the water treatment process is another important environmental factor. PAC usually produces less sludge compared to aluminum sulfate. The large and dense flocs formed by PAC are easier to settle and dewater, resulting in less sludge volume. This reduces the cost and environmental impact associated with sludge disposal.
Application Scenarios
Drinking Water Treatment
In drinking water treatment, the quality and safety of the treated water are of utmost importance. PAC is often preferred over aluminum sulfate due to its better coagulation performance, lower residual aluminum content, and lower sludge production. PAC can effectively remove turbidity, organic matter, and pathogens from the water, ensuring the safety and palatability of the drinking water.
Industrial Wastewater Treatment
Industrial wastewater often contains a variety of pollutants, such as heavy metals, organic compounds, and suspended solids. PAC can be used to treat different types of industrial wastewater, including textile, paper, and food processing wastewater. Its high - efficiency coagulation performance can help to remove these pollutants and meet the discharge standards. Aluminum sulfate may also be used in industrial wastewater treatment, but it may require more complex treatment processes and higher chemical dosages.
Conclusion
In conclusion, polyaluminium chloride PAC has several advantages over aluminum sulfate in water treatment. PAC offers better coagulation performance, lower overall treatment costs, and less environmental impact. As a polyaluminium chloride PAC supplier, I believe that PAC is a more suitable choice for most water treatment applications. If you are looking for a reliable and efficient water treatment solution, I encourage you to consider using PAC. Contact us to discuss your specific water treatment needs and to explore how our PAC products can help you achieve your treatment goals.
References
- Letterman, R. D. (2005). Water Quality and Treatment: A Handbook of Community Water Supplies. McGraw - Hill.
- Gregory, J., & Baranyai, G. (2006). Coagulation and Flocculation. In Encyclopedia of Separation Science. Elsevier.
- Amirtharajah, A., & O’Melia, C. R. (1990). Coagulation and Flocculation. In Water Quality and Treatment: A Handbook of Community Water Supplies. McGraw - Hill.
